How safe is Naturopathy?

I would like to quote from a wonderful article written by Robert Medhurst, BNat ND DHom seeking to quantify the level of risk posed by Australian naturopaths:

Professor Michael Weir of the Faculty of Law at Bond University wrote in a 2016 submission to the Health Workforce Principal Committee on the registration of naturopathy, western herbal medicine and nutritional medicine.  Weir identified the following instances of death and adverse reaction which were directly associated with treatment by a person who was identified solely as an Australian naturopath:

  • 1999 – 1 death as a result of direct intervention by naturopath
  • 2002 – 1 death as a result of direct intervention by naturopath
  • 2004 – 1 adverse reaction as a result of direct intervention by naturopath
  • 2008 – 1 adverse reaction as a result of direct intervention by naturopath
  • 2016 – 1 adverse reaction as a result of direct intervention by naturopath
  • 2016 – 1 adverse reaction as a result of direct intervention by naturopath

In summary, over the 17-year period from 1999, Weir identified 2 deaths and 4 adverse reactions occurring as a result of direct intervention by a naturopath.

Risks associated with Orthodox Medicine compared to Naturopathy

In looking at the risk associated with naturopathy, it may be of benefit to examine the risk associated with the provision of services by a medical practitioner.

The British Medical Journal in 2016 refers to a figure of 400,000 deaths per year from orthodox medical treatments provided in US hospitals.  Extrapolating these figures to Australian populations, the figure here would be something in the order of 31,000 deaths per year making death from orthodox medical treatments provided in hospitals 263,500 times more likely than death resulting from the treatment provided by naturopaths.

A 2006 Victorian study found that the adverse event risk from treatment in Victorian hospitals was 6.88%.  In Australia in the financial year 2016-17, there were 11 million hospital admissions.  At a rate of 6.8%, for the 11 million hospital admissions nationally, 756,800 people would have suffered an adverse event from receiving orthodox medical treatment in hospital.

Ducket and Jorm, writing for the Grattan Institute in February of this year, state that around 900,000 people who are treated in Australian hospitals each year experience an adverse reaction.

According to this date and date from Weir, orthodox medical treatment provided in Australian hospitals is associated with 3,825,000 times more adverse reactions than treatment provided by Australian naturopaths.

Wilson, et al, in a paper published in the Medical Journal of Australia in 1995, which was a review of data from 28 NSW and South Australian hospitals, found an adverse reaction rate of 16.6% and of these a mortality rate of 4.9%.  Using Australian hospital admission data from the financial year 2016/17, this would give an adverse reaction figure of 1,826,000 and 89,474 deaths per annum nationally, indicating that orthodox medical treatments provided in Australian hospitals is 7,760,500 times more likely to cause an adverse reaction and 760,529 times more likely to cause death, than the treatment provided by an Australian Naturopath.

 

There are times when we need Orthodox Medicine or hospital treatments, but there are also times when a Naturopath may be able to help.  Naturopathy needs to be given the support and recognition it deserves – support from our Governments as well as from the media and all branches of health care.

 

Exercising safely

Safety Tips for Your Next Outdoor Workout Session – Article written and submitted by Sheila Olson of fitsheila.com Exercising outdoors is a great feeling. The fresh air feels cleaner, nature is motivating, and sometimes just being outside can make you want to move and bounce around. Being outside also means losing control over the elements, as…

Glyphosate, weed killers and cancer

Glyphosate is the world’s most widely produced herbicide and is the primary toxic chemical in Roundup™, as well as in many other herbicides. In addition, it is a broad-spectrum herbicide that is used in more than 700 different products from agriculture and forestry to home use. Exposure to glyphosate has been linked to autism, Alzheimer’s,…

Oral health & Cardiovascular disease

In a surprising new development in a well-established field, cardiovascular disease has now been shown to be linked to chronic infection by a number of mechanisms.  Chronic infections such as Helicobacter pylori and Porphyromonas gingivalis (from periodontal disease) are now known to colonise the atherosclerotic plaque in a biofilm, initiating chronic inflammation and even autoimmune…

Autoimmune conditions

Autoimmune conditions are varied and complex and may be silent for decades before being diagnosed.  What is quite concerning is the increase in diagnosed autoimmune cases.  Currently it is estimated that 1 in 20 people in Australia and New Zealand suffer from an autoimmune condition. Women are more susceptible than men, raising the question of…

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Of the many different health concerns people present with, fatigue is one of the most common.  More than feeling tired, fatigue affects your ability to function properly.  A few decades ago, the condition of ongoing extremely debilitating fatigue became known as Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS). A syndrome is a combination of symptoms which are common…

EMF, WiFi – are these waves causing your body harm?

Electromagnetic fields of all frequencies represent one of the most common and fastest growing environmental influences, about which anxiety and speculation are spreading. All populations are now exposed to varying degrees of EMF, and the levels will continue to increase as technology advances. (http://www.who.int/peh-emf/en/) EMF are not visible and, as such, are often overlooked as…

Lyme Disease

“There’s a certain percentage of people who have neurodegenerative disease like motor neuron disease, MS, Alzheimer’s, autism and chronic fatigue, who actually have Lyme” says Dr McManus from the Karl McManus Foundation. Lyme Disease is just one of many vector-borne illnesses that is spread by stinging and biting insects.  Vectors are generally considered to include…

Detoxing – the body’s housekeeping

Every day, our bodies are exposed to pollutants and chemicals (external) and endogenous (internal) waste products. We process and eliminate most of these toxins as part of normal detoxification and elimination processes, via the liver, kidneys, intestines, skin, lungs and lymph. However, sometimes detoxification and elimination is impaired due to lifestyle, environmental and/or genetic factors.(1)…

Natural medicines under wrongful fire

On Monday 10 September 2018 the current Governments’ health insurance reform laws were passed by the Senate, which includes the approved removal of 16 natural therapies from the Private Health Insurance rebates. It will now be a straightforward process for those laws to be in place by 01 April 2019. NHMRC Review of Naturopathy  The…